Root problem...
Gardening Reference » Gardening in 2006
by Jiffymouse on October 17, 2006 11:36 AM
depends on how close you cut the roots back. pines usually have a pretty good tap root (the center root that goes straight down for water) so trimming part of the horizontal roots won't be too back. just try not to cut the roots closer than 2-3 feet from the trunk, and if possible, even leave them to the "drip line" of the tree.
by badplanter on October 18, 2006 09:59 AM
Thanks, Jiffy! I didn't plan to get too close to the tree anyway, so this works out just fine!
* * * *
"I don't want no more of army life, gee mom, I wanna go, but they won't let me go, gee mom, I wanna go home!" My PB!
* * * *
"I don't want no more of army life, gee mom, I wanna go, but they won't let me go, gee mom, I wanna go home!" My PB!
by johnCT on October 18, 2006 09:08 PM
It certainly will affect everything growing there as the pine tree will absorb much of the water and nutrients from the soil where the roots are. Your plants will be competing with the tree for needed nutrients and water. Tree roots extend out as much as three times farther then the diameter of the tree's dripline. They really don't have a "taproot". Most plants don't. Their root systems are located mostly in the top couple feet of soil where most of the water and nutrients come from. You really won't hurt a mature tree by taking out some of the roots, but the tree will relentlessly continue to send roots out into your planting bed. When a root is cut, say with a shovel, it will begin to branch out at the cut.
This is not to say that your plants cannot sustain themselves in the shadow of a large tree. The tree will not take ALL nutrients, but you can make it easier on them by making up for the lack of nutrients with more fertilizer or compost.
* * * *
John - Zone 6
This is not to say that your plants cannot sustain themselves in the shadow of a large tree. The tree will not take ALL nutrients, but you can make it easier on them by making up for the lack of nutrients with more fertilizer or compost.
* * * *
John - Zone 6
by Jiffymouse on October 19, 2006 10:00 AM
john, i respectfully differ with you. depending on the type of tree, they can, and do have "tap roots". several types of pines will have a tap root, and i have seen types of pines that the roots are nearly as deep as the tree is tall. in fact, when clearing land, i have seen roots that could be mistaken for logs!
as for the roots affecting the beds, generally, if a pine trees roots are systematically removed from a particular area, they will spread back out, but at a deeper level, giving the bed the upper 18 inches or so of soil for the flowers.
as for the roots affecting the beds, generally, if a pine trees roots are systematically removed from a particular area, they will spread back out, but at a deeper level, giving the bed the upper 18 inches or so of soil for the flowers.
by badplanter on October 19, 2006 10:17 AM
quote:That's more then enough "free" soil... I don't plan to dig that deep, only 8-10 inches.
upper 18 inches or so of soil for the flowers.
I'll just wind up cutting the roots that are spreading a bit past the dripline back. No major roots-I hope!
* * * *
"I don't want no more of army life, gee mom, I wanna go, but they won't let me go, gee mom, I wanna go home!" My PB!
by johnCT on October 19, 2006 08:19 PM
Mark, you believe what you want. Most trees do not have "tap roots". Tap roots are generally a myth. You can do a quick google search and read the multitude of university research articles on the subject of tree root systems and verify it for yourself. Use advice you get in gardening forums as a stepping stone to do your own due diligence. Here are a couple of links I have bookmarked that I think relate to the subject...
http://www.ipm.iastate.edu/ipm/hortnews/1992/4-1-1992/treeroot.html
http://www.ext.colostate.edu/PUBS/Garden/02926.html
http://www.forestry.gov.uk/pdf/fcin078.pdf/$FILE/fcin078.pdf
* * * *
John - Zone 6
http://www.ipm.iastate.edu/ipm/hortnews/1992/4-1-1992/treeroot.html
http://www.ext.colostate.edu/PUBS/Garden/02926.html
http://www.forestry.gov.uk/pdf/fcin078.pdf/$FILE/fcin078.pdf
* * * *
John - Zone 6
by tkhooper on October 19, 2006 10:35 PM
I know that my evergreen sport has a taproot. One that is deeper than the bush is tall, but it doesn't do the small feeder roots just really fat sideways roots that it sends out to start more plants. I love that little guy.
* * * *
* * * *
by M. D. Vaden of Oregon on October 20, 2006 01:17 PM
"Tap Root" sounds like it would make a great name for a beer.
Much of our area has enough rain for trees to root fairly shallow.
Usually it depends on the depth of the soil and how deep available water it.
I find it amazing how trees will grow on the sides of a rock like Beacon Rock in Washington.
But they only get so-old there, as they often grow beyond the limits of the water available in the limited soil between the crags.
* * * *
M. D. Vaden of Oregon
Web Site
Oregon Bigfoot Trap trail
Photo Albums - Oregon Scenery & Tree Care
Much of our area has enough rain for trees to root fairly shallow.
Usually it depends on the depth of the soil and how deep available water it.
I find it amazing how trees will grow on the sides of a rock like Beacon Rock in Washington.
But they only get so-old there, as they often grow beyond the limits of the water available in the limited soil between the crags.
* * * *
M. D. Vaden of Oregon
Web Site
Oregon Bigfoot Trap trail
Photo Albums - Oregon Scenery & Tree Care
Similar discussions:
Search The Garden Helper:
Thanks!
* * * *
"I don't want no more of army life, gee mom, I wanna go, but they won't let me go, gee mom, I wanna go home!" My PB!